Considerations when Working with AI-Native Accounting Firms
It is a great time to be deploying AI to automate accounting and finance. At this point, reconciliations, scenario modeling, and dashboards can easily be done by AI with tuned skills and automated workflows. Any fractional CFO or finance leader worth their salt will know how to use Claude Code or Codex to deploy AI tools internally within the company’s systems perimeter.
That brings me to the primary point of this article, which is a few key items you should consider when choosing an accounting firm and/or fractional CFO.
- Ask about data access, storage and ownership. I am seeing that many AI-native firms require access to sensitive data and storage of that data outside of your systems so they can automate processes using their AI tools. Why does this matter?
- Data privacy and security: while this may not be your core application data, it likely includes customer contracts and associated contact details, payroll data, bank details, etc. You are giving another third party access to connect and store your data. This is likely duplicating what you already have via existing systems like your G-Drive/Sharepoint, ERP, spend management, payroll and data warehouse systems.
- Ownership of the AI automations: the accounting firm will own the automations that are built for your business, providing no residual value for you. This will make the transition from outsourced to insourced more challenging when you ultimately do it.
- Your data contributes to their IP, not yours: this is not necessarily outright bad, and it’s the way many AI-native software providers work today. The difference is these firms are selling a service, but actually building another control panel and context layer over your existing systems that you don’t own. When you’re ready to move from QBO to a new accounting system, you can extract your data and rebuild it into the new system. With your AI-native accounting firm, will you have ownership of your context and data, or has that become a component of their product?
While this may not be an important issue for all startups and SMBs, companies should strongly consider where their data resides and the controls over it.
- Ask what is in vs. out of scope. Many firms don’t want to handle things outside of core accounting, like managing payroll & compliance, forecasting & budgets, and A/R collections. Why does this matter? For many of my smaller clients, I spend a fair amount of time on things like payroll matters, scenario modeling and cash collections. On the payroll side alone, this includes everything from random state notices to missing R&D tax credit checks (yes, $1000s of dollars of lost checks). Automating accounting is easy and relatively low value at this point. Handling the broader scope of work is where real value is provided and where startups often need more bespoke service.
On the other hand, what these firms do provide is an AI-native solution, and ideally you benefit from this through lower cost service (and potentially better or faster). In addition, transition costs don’t completely go away using a traditional outsourced accounting firm and/or fractional CFO. Traditional firms may use close management software, bespoke integrations, MCP servers and custom built skills that require transition if you move firms.
If you are looking for AI-native accounting or fractional CFO solutions, these are just a few of the items worth asking about up front. In my own practice, I use my clients’ AI, and they keep the automations and integrations built for their needs. Their data stays in their systems.